Skip to content
Gold Core Factory

Established Politics Triumphs Over New Ideals in Thai Poll

"Once, I attended a community event for kids and ended up sitting beside another politician. He was holding a bundle of 100 baht notes to distribute to the children, while I had arrived without gifts. How was I supposed to vie with that?"

Chutiphong Pipoppinyo was part of the "progressive surge" of reform-minded newcomers who surprised Thailand in the 2023 election by winning more seats for the forward-thinking movement than any other party.

This year though, he was defeated in his seat in his electoral district of Rayong to a opponent from an long-standing political dynasty which has traditionally held leadership roles there.

"During the last election we were like a storm that swept through and the other parties could not respond. They assumed I was only a no-name candidate. The surge of support for Move Forward in the final stretch of that election genuinely persuaded voters to try something new."

Now renamed the People's Party, their expectations that they would build upon their earlier showing were crushed on the rocks of entrenched patronage networks which have dominated local politics in Thailand throughout its contemporary era.

The tallies are still not finalized, and a number of election anomalies are being investigated, but that cannot reverse the broad result: a sharp drop of over 20% in the count of seats gained by the People's Party, and a notable rise by the conservative Bhumjaithai party, increasing its number of seats from 71 in 2023 to an estimated 193 in the five-hundred-member parliament now.

'They never spoke to me anymore'

Following gaining his seat in 2023, Chutiphong threw himself into his new job, travelling around his district aiming to address the problems faced by his voters. But he swiftly met pushback from those aligned with the entrenched influential figures. Furthermore, he discovered he was pressured to make substantial contributions, from resources he simply did not have.

"An invitation was extended to me to a women's rights event - a common function for the community members to join and enjoy themselves. But they informed me if I wished to come, I needed to give 25,000 baht. I explained I lacked that money. They were very unhappy about that and said I was unfeeling. I inquired if there was another way I could assist. But they ceased communicating with me from then on."

What he had run up against was a deep-rooted system of clientelism run by a powerful family.

Rayong is best known as a component of the Eastern Economic Corridor, Thailand's biggest manufacturing hub, hosting many of the industrial facilities which power its trade-reliant economy. This has brought in migrant workers from different areas, and also led to an metropolitan populace which is more receptive to the reformist ideas of the progressive movement.

In 2023, Move Forward won all five seats there.

But much of Rayong is still agricultural, the domain of farmers and fruit growers. This is especially the case in District 4, where Chutipong won his seat. He is a local man, but lived several years based in California. The province has for decades been ruled by a prominent local household, the Pitutecha family. This is what is termed in Thailand as "Baan Yai" – big house – politics, and throughout the country it is the method provincial control has always been maintained.

Pitutechas control much of the municipal administration.

Piya 'Chang' Pitutecha, the present patriarch, is the chosen leader of the Provincial Administration Organisation (PAO), a extremely powerful post as the PAO controls most official budgets in Rayong.

Prior to 2023, Pitutechas had always been among the MPs elected to parliament, with one serving as the vice-minister for health in Bangkok.

Similar to other "Baan Yai" families they have no particular allegiance – over time they have represented five different political parties. They are also prominent in the local business community, and, in contrast to Chutipong, have ample funds to dispense. It was virtually hopeless for the rookie MP to challenge.

The "Baan Yai" depend on extensive networks of local agents - community members who understand their areas, and who organize voters to vote for their candidate. And although it is formally forbidden, they also hand out money before, during, and after elections. They have always been vital to the victory of provincial hopefuls, and as a recent, predominantly city-based party, the People's Party had lacked them.

"So I modified my approach," says Chutipong. "I announced that I would seek to fix all issues promptly. If your water is not flowing, your electricity has failed, your road has craters, I would assist."

"But the residents who called me in then faced intimidation from the established system. Some were chastised in the village's chat group or through the PA system in the village. They were accused of bringing me - a stranger they said - into the area."

"When I tried to investigate factories after hearing some allegations about environmental damage, I faced a hostile response from local communities because they had been getting payments from these factories."

By the time of the latest election cycle, the Pitutechas had learned from their defeat in the last election.

In those electoral areas, they fielded more youthful members of the family, better educated and with a reduced patriarchal aura than the older generation. In District 3 they stood under the Democrat party, historically their chosen political partner, but in District 4, 34-year-old Chatchai Pitutecha campaigned under Prime Minister Anutin Charvirakul's Bhumjaithai party, renowned for its wealth and its expertise in winning "Baan Yai" over to his side.

Chutipong was overwhelmed.

The Pitutechas regained the two constituencies back from the People's Party, while the progressives held onto three seats in Rayong.

"They might have welcomed me if I had offered them money, but I was unable to do that forever considering my modest means. I had to choose whether I would be the representative they expected, or whether I would hold onto my principles and find out if the voters would

KW
About the author

Kelly Wise

Marcus Sterling is a financial analyst specializing in precious metals, with over 15 years of experience in global markets and investment strategies.

Gold Core Factory

Type to search articles.